This Chatsworth stabbing update reveals that the State has strongly opposed bail for a man accused of a brutal attack at a Silverglen pool lounge, arguing that he poses a danger to the public as the victim remains in a coma in hospital.
Missed the original story? CLICK HERE TO Read our full report on the stabbing incident that led to the current court proceedings
Mahendra Ramandrah (46) appeared in the Durban Magistrate’s Court on charges of attempted murder and assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm following a violent incident at a pool lounge in Silverglen.
During bail proceedings, prosecutors told the court that the main complainant, Keith Govender, remains in the intensive care unit at Chatsmed Hospital in a medically induced coma due to swelling of the brain. The court heard that, according to information received from the family, further surgery may still be required.
The State argued that the seriousness of the injuries, combined with the use of a knife, demonstrated a high level of violence. Prosecutors added that a conviction could result in a sentence of up to 15 years’ imprisonment, which may motivate the accused to interfere with witnesses or the ongoing investigation if released on bail.
The incident allegedly occurred at around 10pm at the pool lounge in Silverglen. Investigating officer Warrant Officer Elizabeth Ramrattan testified that two witnesses saw the accused stab Keith following an argument over a game. Keith sustained multiple stab wounds and collapsed at the scene.
A second victim, an employee at the venue who attempted to intervene, was also stabbed during the altercation.
The knife allegedly used in the attack was later recovered by police.
The investigating officer confirmed that the accused and the complainant were known to each other and were described as friends. Police profiling further revealed that Ramandrah has no previous convictions or pending cases and provided an alternative address approximately three kilometres away from the complainant’s home.
The defence argued that Ramandrah acted in self-defence, cooperated with police and handed himself over. Advocate P Naicker further submitted that there had been no intimidation of witnesses and questioned whether the accused would pose a danger to the community if released on bail. The defence also cited Ramandrah’s employment and the fact that he has a minor child.
However, the State disputed the self-defence claim, telling the court that the victim was unarmed and that the accused allegedly fought with Keith before producing a knife. Prosecutors also rejected the claim that Ramandrah voluntarily surrendered, stating that police first went to his residence before he later presented himself.
During cross-examination, the investigating officer was asked whether offences of this nature were prevalent in the area. She testified that such violent incidents were not common in Silverglen.
The State confirmed that it is awaiting the J88 medical report from the treating doctor, which is expected to be submitted soon.
Ramandrah remains in custody, as the magistrate has reserved judgment on the bail application. A ruling is expected on Monday.
Meanwhile, Keith remains in a critical condition in hospital. His family has appealed to the public for assistance to help cover mounting medical expenses.
Family spokesperson Nicole Boodhun said the family remains hopeful but deeply concerned about his recovery.
